
In his comment to my last post, reader and blogger Terence Amos asks me to be more specific about the lenses I use to shoot my photographs. I'm aware I will disappoint many photographer friends, but I always use zoom lenses. At least in the last five years.
Of course I begun my photo adventure long before zooms got popular among photographers. Prime lenses were the only available lenses at the time. Almost all 35 mm bodies were sold with a bundled 50 mm "normal" lens. The addition of a 28 mm and a 135 mm (and perhaps a budget duplicator) was the standard way for a teenager to get a basic kit. In the welthier bags, one could find 20 or 21 mm wide angles (I was fond of my third-hand non-AI Nikkor UD 20 mm f 3.5), and/or 200 or 400 mm long telephoto lenses. Extreme angle lovers dared circular fish-eyes. I remember I diy'd one assembling a lens cap and a door's peephole lens bought at a hardware shop.
Then came my career as a pro. My Nikon F bodies, my Leicas, my Hasselblad, my 4x5 inch Arca Swiss and Linhof were all equipped with the best prime lenses I could afford. In 1980, for an assignment job, I gave in to the temptation of the Nikkor 43-86 f 3.5, definitely the worst lens I have ever experienced. Which pushed me back to the primes.
The best performing lens I have ever had was a Summicron 35 mm non-asph. With an M4-P body it made a dream couple. Moreover, after my switch to digital, it was the perfect match with the Epson R-D1's sensor (better than my old AI Nikkor glasses on Nikon D1x and D200 bodies). Until the day I borrowed my wife Daniela's 18-200 mm Nikon DX zoom. Suddenly I could forget about dust-on-sensor troubles, leave one kilogram (more than two pounds) of prime lenses at home and be ever ready to shoot, whitout the hassle of lens switching. Mind you, I'm not claiming it outperforms some (not any) good primes. I only say that it made possible taking shots I could never take without it, and that its few (and easily adjustable) flaws are negligible, compared to its indisputable advantages. It has been the fundamental tool in a huge project of mine on cargo boats (which will be finalized in 2011), where I had to continuously switch between focals while shooting from a moving ship.
My love story with zoom lenses had begun. Then came the Canon G10, with its excellent built-in 5x zoom glass, the pocket-sized Panasonic TZ-65, with its astounding 12x, and the Panasonic G1, with its bundled (and prime-level) 14-45. Except that more extended zooms had already spoiled me. So I bought the Panasonic 14-140, which definitely outperforms the though satisfactory 18-200 Nikon, and is permanently mounted on my GF1 (this is the answer I owed Terence).
Can I have a final word about my ideal lens?
A Micro Four Thirds, non-interchangeable, firmware-corrected, compact and self-collapsing barrel, self-closing cap, 28-300 mm equivalent. So that I can stop fussing about lenses and concentrate on the imaging process.
I know, prime lenses have an undeniable charm. As sailing boats have. But the best way I know to cross the ocean is flying. Even though I must confess I enjoy sailing, every now and then.
Addendum: the Panasonic 20 mm pancake is a little gem. If only I had more chances to use it!